Great Lakes Water Management Initiative
A Statement on Protecting the Great Lakes: Managing Diversions
and Bulk Water Exports
October 15, 1999
The waters and the water-dependent resources of the Great Lakes
Basin are precious public natural resources, shared and held in
trust by the Great Lakes States and Provinces. As trustees of the
Basin's natural resources, we, the Great Lakes Governors, in cooperation
with the Great Lakes Premiers of Ontario and Quebec, have a shared
duty to protect, conserve and manage the Great Lakes waters and
ecosystem.
We, the Great Lakes Governors, take our authority as stewards of
the Great Lakes very seriously and have been vigilant in ensuring
the protection of the Great Lakes ecosystem. In exercising our authority,
our primary goal is the protection of the integrity of the Great
Lakes and the Great Lakes ecosystem.
We have, in cooperation with the Great Lakes Premiers of Ontario
and Quebec, effectively exercised our authority under the Great
Lakes Charter of 1985, a good faith agreement to collectively manage
the Great Lakes and its ecosystem. We have abided by its prior notice
and consultation process on proposals for diversions and consumptive
uses of Great Lakes water.
In addition, we have effectively exercised our authority under
Section 1109 of the U.S. Water Resources Development Act of 1986
(WRDA). New bulk exports or diversions of Great Lakes water from
the Great Lakes Basin can not occur in the United States without
the unanimous approval of the Great Lakes Governors. There have
been three proposals to divert water from the Great Lakes since
the passage of the WRDA, none of which was for bulk export. The
review of each of these proposals took a minimum of one year in
order to assess their potential impact on the ecosystem. Two proposals
were approved with conditions that ensure the on-going protection
of the Great Lakes, and one proposal was not approved.
There are no proposals to export Great Lakes water at this time
nor do we anticipate any being submitted within the next year. Management
of the Great Lakes ecosystem confronts us with new and ongoing challenges,
including the bulk export of water. We must continually identify
ways to secure the protection of the resource. We will review any
proposals made to divert or export water from the Great Lakes with
the same vigor as we have reviewed past proposals. We, the Great
Lakes Governors, have the authority and we will exercise it appropriately
to address any attempts to export bulk quantities of Great Lakes
waters.
For the last fifteen years, we have followed a set of principles
to guide us in developing, maintaining and strengthening the regional
management regime for the Great Lakes ecosystem. We strongly believe
that any change to the current management regime must be aligned
with these principles:
- It must protect the resource. Resource protection, restoration,
and conservation must be the foundation for the legal standard
upon which decisions concerning water withdrawals are based.
- It must be durable. The framework for decisions must be able
to endure legal challenges based upon, but not limited to, interstate
commerce and international trade. It must be constitutionally
sound on a bi-national basis, and the citizens of the Basin must
support this framework.
- It must be simple. The process for making decisions and resolving
disputes should be straightforward, transparent and based on common
sense.
- It must be efficient. Implementation of the decision making
process should engage existing authorities and institutions without
necessitating the establishment of new and large bureaucracies.
The decision making process should be flexible and responsive
to the demands it will confront.
- It must retain authority in the Basin. Decision-making must
remain vested in those authorities, the Great Lakes Governors
and Premiers, who manage the resource on a day-to-day basis.
We encourage those who share our concern for the Great Lakes to
join with us in abiding by these principles. We will continue to
work with Ontario Premier Mike Harris and Quebec Premier Lucien
Bouchard, state legislators, the Great Lakes U.S. Congressional
delegation and the International Joint Commission to ensure that
the authority to protect and manage the waters of the Great Lakes
is strong, secure and retained within the Basin.
- To assure the continued protection of the Great Lakes, today
we pledge to:
- Develop a new agreement, based upon the Great Lakes Charter
and its principles, which will bind the Great Lakes States and
Provinces more closely to collectively plan, manage and make decisions
regarding the protection of the waters of the Great Lakes.
- Develop a new common standard against which water projects
will be reviewed. It will be based upon the standard that we have
developed with the Premiers, but have never formally adopted:
the protection of the integrity of the Great Lakes ecosystem.
- Secure funds to develop a better base of Great Lakes water
use data. Without a good base of data, it is difficult to make
sound decisions. We applaud the actions of The Great Lakes Protection
Fund which has, by unanimous vote of its board at their last meeting
in Chicago, agreed that funding the design and development of
a water-use information system is the Fund's highest priority
for the next year.
We, as stewards of twenty percent of the world's freshwater, will
be vigilant in protecting, conserving, preserving and managing the
Great Lakes. It is incumbent upon us, the Great Lakes Governors
and Premiers, to protect the waters that we all enjoy and are dependent
upon.
View The Governors' Letter to the International
Joint Commission
|